Gretchen's Shelf

Monday, June 20, 2011

Top 10 Challenged Books

For the year 2010, And Tango Makes Three is once again the most challenged book. I had read this book and honestly, it has its place. Would I want a five-year-old reading this book? Absolutely not. On the other hand, I think this book opens the door for discussion when a child is ready. I was very suprised to see that Twilight was one of the top ten challenged books. I have read the entire series, and I see nothing wrong with any of the books and would recommend those books to my students. As a parent, I also understand why children should not have access to certain books without parent permission. I think students should be exposed to materials when they are mature and able to understand the suject matter, and I think parents would best know this for their child. Will I let my daughter read some of these books? I will when I think she is old enough, and I will make sure we discuss the book and its content together. I think as long as parents are aware, students should be able to read what they want.

1 comment:

  1. I definitely agree that And Tango Makes Three is not appropriate for a five year old. However, at the appropriate age the book could be used to start a great discussion with ones child. I think that most of the challenged books offer a great way to start a discussion about topics that are hard to bring up or start talking about between parents and their child/children.

    ReplyDelete